Monday, October 7, 2013

Swim

How to Swim in a Burqa
1. Update will.
2. Don said burqa.
3. Proceed to the deep end of the pool.
4. Say farewell to family and friends.
5. Dive in!
6. Enjoy your last, surreal moments as you helplessly sink straight to the bottom - the billowing black cloth transformed into your funeral shroud.
 
This was the image that came to my mind as I sat in Mutual one Wednesday night. As a matter of business we were discussing the upcoming Young Women's Camp, and some rules and guidelines were being reviewed. The one that set off my flight of imagination was this one:
 
"All young women are to wear one-piece bathing suits while at camp. No two-piece suits or bikinis allowed. You are also required to wear knee-length shorts and a t-shirt over your swimming suit at all times - even while in the pool."
 
Say what!? These are girls. Attending girls camp. Girls - get it! Not boys. Not co-ed. Girls!! My BS-ometer instantly pegged over into the red zone! Were the Young Men given the same sort of requirements for Boy Scout Camp? No! As a Scout Leader and veteran of numerous Scout encampments and Jamborees, I can say unequivocably and from personal experience that the boys have no such standards of modesty. This is a double-standard. Again.
 
I have no idea where this directive came from, but at this point I shouldn't be surprised. For the past few yeas I've become more and more aware of the negative and injurious policies we frequently perpetuate against women - and especially Young Women - in the Church. But women are starting to speaking out, and some men are evidently beginning to listen.
 
One account I read that really hit me where it counts was about a Stake Priesthood Meeting. The Stake President invited Bishops to come forward and report on what they had done to prepare the Young Men for Priesthood and Missionary service. The Bishops were eager to share. Many heart-felt stories were told of time spent, tears shed, blessings given, and the miraculous transformation of testimonies as wayward young men were saved from the clutches of the World . Then the Stake President asked each Bishop to come back up and share the stories of how they had helped prepare the Young Women.
 

 
............ < cricket-chirp >............
 

 
The awkwardness that followed was a powerful lesson. And a sad commentary.
 
From the way we teach modesty and chastity standards; to the activites, lessons and programs we design for them,  to the time Priesthood leaders spend with them -  Young Women get the short end of the stick. And you better believe that the girls know it! The tragic thing is, it doesn't have to be this way. Much of our treatment towards women in the Church is based on tradition or policy - not on doctrine. We saw an example of this the last General Conference, where women offered prayers for the first time ever. There was never any doctrinal prohibition against women praying, it was simply tradition. A bad one.
 
And women are now speaking out about these issues as never before.  Consider this FAIR article by Neylan McBaine.  Sis. McBaine is an active, faithful Latter-Day Saint who also happens to be a creative director at Bonneville Communications, and has worked on several projects of note, including the I'm A Mormon campaign and The Mormon Women Project. What's even more huge is that her research has been used by the likes of Michael Otterson, which means this stuff is filtering all the way to the top.

Sis. McBaine's excellent article (which I think should be required reading for all male Leadership) underscores the reality that the way women are treated by the Church, both in the way their role is defined and the way in which our Patriarchal culture tends to marginalize them, is leading to a crisis of faith for many women, both young and old. In her words, "The pain is real." From the way we conduct councils of the Church to the amount of money we spend on the Young Women's program, women are treated inequitably in many ways.
 
Another voice in the chorus of women speaking out that I have especially been impressed by is a group called  All Are Alike Unto God. On their web site, they offer a list of suggestions as to what the Church can do RIGHT NOW to change policies and traditions that marginalize and harm women of all ages. Its brilliant! Here are a few pertient examples:
 
> Create parity in the Young Women and Young Men organizations through equivalent budgets, educational programs (leadership, career, and spiritual training,) and activities (sports, service, and outdoor events).
> Balance the stories and images of boys and men in church publications, talks, and other media with stories and images of girls and women.
> Invite women in Church leadership positions to speak and pray during General Conference in numbers equal to the participation of men. Encourage leaders to use gender-inclusive language whenever possible.
> Recognize that girls and boys, women and men are equally responsible for appropriate sexual behavior, and avoid reducing morality to sexuality, and modesty to a preoccupation with women’s and girls’ clothing.
 
> Call women to perform pastoral counseling, particularly for women and girls who have been sexually abused.
 
> Delegate more expansive supervisory authority to the Stake and Ward Relief Society, Young Women, and Primary presidencies, including approval of personnel, programs, and activities.
 
> Examine all Church positions to determine whether they can be filled without regard to gender.
 
> Call young women as well as young men to serve missions at the same age and for the same length of time, and afford women the same opportunity as men to function as district leaders, zone leaders, and assistants to the president.
 
 
Its time to put an end to the inequities and (often ridiculous) double-standards Young Women must navigate as they experience their journey through the programs of the Church. What are your ideas on how we could improve our program for Young Women and show them they are indeed precious Daughters of God, EQUAL in His sight?
 
 
 


 

7 comments:

Kelly slash FindingMyWay said...

Wow! I love you more today than I did yesterday... and you've always been my fav!

Thank you for the support and love. It means so much.

<3 <3 <3

Kelly slash FindingMyWay said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Neal said...

Kelly, you are so sweet and such an awesome support. Love you!

emerdean said...

As always, Neal, you hit the nail squarely on the head.
It brought to mind two stories from my high-spirited mother - both from when she chaperoned my sisters and her friends when they went to Youth Conferences in the 1960's. The first occurred when my sisters were aged 13 and 14. All the girls in the Sunday School class and MIA group were 14 except my 13 year old sister. She was grouped with the older girls for everything. When it came time to go to Youth Conference, my mother had - of course - volunteered to drive and to chaperone at a nearby university dorm. She was informed that, unfortunately, my 13 year old sister would not be able to attend due to "the rules." Never to be outdone, she said that she understood. She would need to stay home to supervise my 13 year old sister and would be unable to drive the other girls to Youth Conference, or to chaperone them. Hmmm. Guess who went to Youth Conference?
The other incident was when one of the girls asked what she should do since she didn't have a robe to wear down the hall from the dorm room (completely girls floor...) to the bathroom to take a shower. Mom reported said: "I don't care if you leap frog up and down the hall in the nude, honey. Just get going so we can have some fun."
We need to stop acting like sheep. Call a spade a spade, as far as the absurd goes.
Mom was quite forward thinking, I guess. I'm glad that others are moving ahead, as well, and using their minds.
Thank you, Neal, for all you do to keep thinking about what makes sense.

Anonymous said...

I know this is a semi-old post, however since I just came upon it....(by the way I loved it)

I feel like the church is concentrating on the [relative] minority of women asking for the priesthood rather than the [larger] issue of the treatment and equality of women. Whenever there is a talk or article on the subject by a church leader they point out how priesthood is doctrine and the rest is the church "culture." Well then, I ask, where does this "culture" come from. Surely it is a learned behavior. Judging by the many documented talks and articles by those given the authority to speak with and interpret God- these cultures are being taught perpetuated from way up top.
It is easy to focus on such a contentious issue- priesthood for women-because they can then ignore the real issues!

ellie said...

It is also extremely dangerous to swim in clothes. Ask any lifeguard or water expert and they will tell you that wet clothes will weigh a person down. This increases the risk of drowning. This is even more worrisome when dealing w/inexperienced swimmers- which many of these young people are).

ellie said...

I also wanted to say: that the more the church spreads and grows through out the international community; the more I think it is ridiculous that the church adheres to almost entirely American (United States) customs.
Modesty, dating, dancing, hair length and and a number of other customs outlined by the General Authorities and in such guidelines as "For the Strength of Youth" are not the same in every area of the world.
I recently read an article by a Maori woman discussing why she left the church. She was still a believer, however she felt that she was being split in two. Tattoos (facial on women) are an extremely important aspect of the Maori culture. For her it was an important part of her identity as a Maori woman. Because of the "rules" against and the stigma associated with these tattoos, Maori woman are put in a pretty sh#tty position. She finally chose to honor her family, her culture and herself by getting the facial tattoos done and living the gospel without the church. Another article I read (in some LDS publication), talked about how important Native Americans are to the history of the church. The article spoke of "opening our arms" to their Lamonite brothers and sisters and their culture. In order to pray for and pass the sacrament all males must have "appropriate" hair- that is- short. Well, in the Native American culture long hair holds an important significance. The same could be said of people of color and "afros" or braids, the men in the middle east (it may be based on Muslim beliefs, but it is also an important cultural aspect of the entire area. This is why the soldiers over there are allowed to grow beards and longer hair. The length of the beard basically shows how 'manly' they are- even the non- Muslims) These examples are only for the men, the list of cultural differences among women could fill the page.

Sorry I kind of went on and on, but this is one of my biggest problems with the LDS church.